Ministry to Babysit EXCO

The board will immediately act on all the AG's findings on HR and wasteful expenditure at SABC - by instituting legal /criminal proceedings against perpetrators.

It is in full agreement with AG that the underlying causes have been:

  • Lack of quality reporting, governance arrangements and leadership oversight
  • Inadequate monitoring and oversight by the leadership of the SABC
  • The creation of an environment where "the tone at the top" is “inappropriate”.
  • A culture where management is not focused on public accountability or acting
    in the best interest of the SABC".

Some Findings:

  • At least 34 employees were suspended for an average of 10.4months - in some cases for up to 39 months - on full pay, at a cost of R8.3-million
  • 7 tenders awarded for an aggregate amount of R174-million were NOT approved by the appropriate levels stipulated in the delegation of authority framework.
  • 20 employees at the broadcaster are directors or members of companies that had received payments from the SABC to the amount of R3,4-million.
  • 2 contract awards amounting to R8,4-million and R8,2-million, were not approved in accordance with the DAF.
  • The former CEO entered into a material agreement for R326-million with a consultant in September 2006, even though he did not have the authority to do so.
  • No corrective action had been taken by EXCO to address deficiencies in the acquisition of international program content, despite the advice of a forensic investigation in August 2007.
  • Irregularities of R111,75-million relating to:
    • Double payments
    • Overpayments
    • Material paid for but not received
    • Agreements that had to be renegotiated
    • Program titles acquired more than once, from the same supplier.
  • Concerns and detailed findings were brought to the attention of the Acting group CEO in September 2008, but NO corrective actions were implemented!
  • R11,3-million was paid to a private travel company (instead of SABC Travel Office), in contravention of the SABC's travel policy.
  • SABC board members and Execs who travelled with their partners to the Olympic Games were liable for tax arising from the fringe benefits in terms of the Income Tax Act - however, payroll was not notified of the benefits so did not levy the tax to execs or board members.
  • An "environment where management and those responsible for oversight were perceived as being indecisive" and contributed to an organisational culture of "impunity".

THE MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATIONS WILL:

* Conduct a thorough assessment and clearly define roles of and the authority allocated to executive and/or senior managers.

* Review Human Resource policies and implementation thereof.

* Review benefits applicable to management in particular and staff in general.

* Review policies governing the involvement of employees in private business activities.

* Requesting monthly management accounts from the SABC.

* Active and permanent shareholder participation in the various committees of the SABC board, i.e. Risk, Audit and Internal Audit Committees.

* Ensuring that all major decisions, financial or otherwise, have the full approval of the Group Executive Committee, the Board of Directors and the Shareholder.

* General compliance with the Public Finance Management Act (PFMA).

* Require monthly operational reports to monitor implementation.

* Conduct a need analysis of SABC channels to determine the type and amount of content they require.

* Monitor the implementation of the local content quota and conduct a thorough assessment of the need for and the acquisition of international content and ensuring that content is used.

CALL TO ACTION:

Please assist the Ministry in understanding the reasons it took such a long time for this sad state of affairs to surface.

The Ministry of Communications will thoroughly scrutinize previous reports of the Auditor General and SABC internal and external auditors.

* * PLEASE CONTACT THE MINISTRY IF YOU ARE AWARE OF ANY OLD REPORTS THAT HAVE BEEN SUPPRESSED BY EXCO AND HR. * *

Where transgressions are found to have been committed (especially covering up), law enforcement agencies will move swiftly in bringing the perpetrators to book.

Ministerial Statement:
The SABC is a crucial institution of our democracy and everything should be done to save it from further ruin. It is the main and reliable source of information and entertainment services for the public, particularly the needy, providing broadcasting services to 24 million people on a daily basis.

We are encouraged by the conclusion of the process of selecting members of the SABC Board, pending the ratification of the recommended candidates by the President. We believe that this is a major milestone that will undoubtedly create an enabling environment for the efficient implementation of the recovery measures for the SABC.

We are equally grateful for the sterling work done by the interim board since it took office almost three months ago under challenging conditions.

PS: Mr Minister - why not thank the Shop Stewards? Surely their personal sacrifices (without expectation of reward) to expose this rot should count for more than the unhelpful "Interimmers"? - who has done nothing to put a stop to whistleblower victimisation?

12 comments:

  1. Anonymous23/9/09

    The old reports against Ntenteni, Morobe and their ilk must be sent to the Minister. But who is going to check that the Minister actually procecutes them? It will be up to Cde Mimi and Rian again, as usual.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous23/9/09

    At least the ANC has thanked us for "guts and vigilance":

    Sep 22, 2009 at 03:08 PM
    Issued by: ANC

    For immediate release:

    AUDITOR GENERAL'S REPORT ON THE SABC

    The Office of the ANC Chief Whip welcomes the report of the Auditor General on the investigation conducted at the SABC. The
    investigation was requested by the Portfolio Committee on Communications in July following allegations made by some SABC Board members and labour unions on matters relating to potential fruitless expenditure, supply chain management and human resource, amongst others.

    The report, amongst other things, found that there were gross violations of supply chain management policies, fruitless and wasteful expenditure as well as general lack of compliance with procurement policies.

    The Office of the Chief Whip wishes to congratulate the Office of the Auditor General for speedily dealing with this matter and
    for the quality work it put into the investigation. We also commend the Interim Board and Senior Executive Managers for their
    cooperation during the cause of this investigation. The labour unions must also be credited for their vigilance and guts to raise
    these serious allegations.

    The Office of the Chief Whip is satisfied with the comprehensive plan presented by the Interim Board to implement the findings of
    the AG's report. This will include ensuring that those found to have been involved in malpractices and looting of the institution's
    financial resources are dealt with without delay. The law must indeed take its course to ensure that the activities that have resulted in, amongst others, the reported financial loss of R839 million for the 2008/09 financial year are rooted out once and for all.

    The interim and the incoming Board must put in place a seamless transition plan that will ensure that the process of implementing
    the recommendations of the AG are not interrupted or negatively affected.

    Issued by
    The Office of the ANC Chief Whip
    Parliament of the Republic of SA
    Cape Town, 8000

    22 September 2009

    Enquiries:
    Moloto Mothapo 082 370 6930

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous23/9/09

    why are we not suprised about the findings....remains to be seen whether ACTION will be taken ...remains to be seen.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous28/9/09

    Comrade Ben, I've read the AG's report and I'm happy with the findings. WHEN IS RIAN GOING TO BE REINSTATED?

    ReplyDelete
  5. We must await Irene Charnley's ruling on the request from Cde Vulture to lift Cde Rian's suspension.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anonymous29/9/09

    thank you Comrade Ben.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Anonymous29/9/09

    I believe Irene Charnley ignores us, and does not take a bit of time to respond. What should we do?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Anonymous29/9/09

    I don't think Rian or the shop stewards are important at this moment. We should all be glad about the suspensions and then there can be concentrated on Rian and the shop stewards again.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous30/9/09

    The problem is that there is not nearly enough suspensions yet - and the Shop Stewards are good for monitoring that ALL the perpetrators get suspended, charged and their asstes forfeited. The money is needed for our substantives - and the Shop Stewards are key.

    Your comment therefore makes little sense - if the Shop Stewards do not put the pressure, do you think things will go well?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Anonymous1/10/09

    Will you allow me to be cynical here? Ask yourself why the board isn't interested in reinstating shop stewards who can ask a lot of questions. Some of the people involved here are VERY well connected. Look at Chuene if you doubt this, he still has his job. I suspect a couple of (maybe Mbeki supporters) people will take a fall and the whole thing will blow over.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Anonymous1/10/09

    Anonymous - you are not cynical. You are wise - that's exactly what will happen. Mbebe is a house friend of Zuma's. He's the biggest culprit of the lot, but he's gonna be the new coo.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Anonymous2/10/09

    WE WANT OUR SHOP STEWARDS BACK NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Are you willing to defend the organisational rights of the union?

Can Cde Rian expect a fair hearing from these SABC managers?

By refusing to see our value, the SABC negotiators are:

Who currently keeps the SABC on air?

SEF has convinced Jane Duncan (freedom of expression champion) to accept our nomination, only if it comes from us

The counter proposal is:

Should CWU/MWASA refer the "agreement" signed by "SMS ballot" to CCMA for adjudication?

The letter to SABC Board is hereby:

Who can save the SABC?

What is the main reason you will strike?

What should the Minister do to stop the strike?

Who should we negotiate with?

Important Vote - Build the SABC

When you vote on this blog, your views are seen by the Minister, New Board, Exco, SMF, SOS campaign, TVIEC, ICASA, and the owners - the People of South Africa.

ONLY VOTE ONCE!, When it is the square tickboxes, first select ALL the blocks you agree with, then press "Vote".

ALL COMRADES MUST PLEASE VOTE! - pass it on - Shop Steward Janine Murison has been denied an opportunity to present the truth in Labour Court. Please mandate the Way Forward:

Which of the following are most responsible for the financial freefall at the SABC?

For Waste, Secrecy, Arrogance, and (Allegations), we Demand the Suspension and Invesigation of:

What is the best type of increase for you?

Who should resign?

Should SABC EXCO refuse our demands, will you: